Myths of Philanthropy series

April 9, 2025

1

minute read
Various contributors

In this special feature series, contributors from across the philanthropic sector will identify the dominant narratives that underpin common practices, and explore interventions that can redesign philanthropy in ways that set us up to succeed.

The Myths of Philanthropy: What if we change the narratives that govern the philanthropic sector?

Mandy Van Deven introduces a new series of articles exploring the narratives that underpin common practices in the philanthropic sector, inviting us to unravel the myths that are limiting what we can achieve.

Photo of Mandy Van Deven, Co-lead, Elemental. Quote: "This series will highlight work that has long been happening to uncover and address some of the harmful narratives that drive philanthropy"

A path to repair: What if philanthropy wasn't about giving money away, but returning it?

Lisa Cowan argues that rather than thinking of themselves as strategic gatekeepers, grant-makers might think of themselves as creative stewards who are trying to get money back to its original owners.

Photo of Lisa Pilar Cowan, Vice President, Robert Sterling Clark Foundation. Quote: "I wonder if there is a different story that we could be telling... What would it look like if we were deliberate and transparent in talking about how philanthropic dollars were amassed?"

Positioning and Repositioning: What if what we inherited doesn’t have to be the legacy we leave?

Setting up a foundation with inherited wealth led Louisa Mann to question many of the norms of philanthropy - and the wealth management system that underpins it. She shares how Thirty Percy and its partners began to imagine alternatives.

Photo of Louisa Mann, chair, Thirty Percy. Quote: "In the world of excess wealth, even when there is more than enough, the operatinng principles is, perversely, one of scarcity"

Spending stories: moving from perpetuity to purpose

Dimple Abichandani proposes a new narrative to guide foundation spending in this time of crisis - one that is based neither on arbitrary timeframes, nor on the insignificance of our giving, but on the purpose of the spending, and of philanthropy itself.

Photo of Dimple Abichandani, philnahtropy advisor and author. Quote: "Simply put, if fulfilling a foundation's mission or strategy requires greater spending today, a perpetuity goal may directly conflict with that purpose"

Leaning Into Abundance: What If Philanthropy’s Potential Wasn’t Limited by Manufactured Scarcity?

Zaineb Mohammed argues that a "scarcity mindset" is holding philanthropy back, and shares how the Kataly Foundation have designed their grant-making from a place of abundance.

Photo o Zaineb Mohammed, Director of communication, Kataly Foundation. Quote: "Building and sustaining strong and resilient movements requires attending to and recognizing the valuable role each part of the whole plays"

If You Know You Know: What If Philanthropy is Mistaking Wealth for Expertise?

Whose Knowledge? calls for philanthropy to grapple with its historical conviction that certain ways of knowing and speaking are more valuable than others, and expand its understanding of who and what counts.

Photos of Cassie Denbow, elyss marcellin and Anasuya Sengupta. Quote: "Community-led funds rapidly shift power and money directly into the hands of those bearing the brunt of our modern polycrisis"

Reconsidering Our Relationship to Power: What If Philanthropy’s Greatest Resource Isn’t Financial but Relational Capital?

Tesmerelna Atsbeha shares the truths she has learned, as both a grant-maker and a funding recipient, about how to build and sustain relationships of shared power and purpose that move us toward the future we desire.

Photo of Tesmerelna Atsbeha. Quote: "The strogest measure of effective grantmaking practice is the quality of the relationship between grantmakers and grantees"

Change is a Process: What if philanthropy had the courage to take its cues from nature?

Inspired by nature’s ebb and flow, the Constellations Culture Change Fund set out to apply experimental practices that are critical for resourcing narrative change, write Erin Lynn Williams and Ilegvak.

Photos of Erin Lynn Williams and Ilegvak. Quote: "Funders should practice humility by trusting the wisdom of their community, those they are supporting, and ultimately, nature's ways"

Solidarity Leadership: What If Philanthropy Encouraged Collaboration Rather Than Competition?

The three co-founders of Closer Than You Think share what they learned about collaboration and competition as foundation leaders - and why these lessons are so important in a time of uncertainty and rapid change.

Photos of Devi Leiper O'Malley, Ruby Johnson and Swatee Deepak. Quote: We were able to adopt new forms of leadership, with the aim to prove that an ethic of care was more impactful than an ethos of competition"

The Future is Ours to Make: What If Solidarity Was the Blueprint for Philanthropy?

All over the world, Black feminists are fighting to preserve hard won gains and freedoms. It’s time for more people in philanthropy to follow their lead by being equally visionary and creative in how we redistribute money, writes Vanessa Thomas.

Photo of Vanessa Thomas, Program Manager, Black Feminist Fund. Quote: "It is past time for funders who care about racial and gender justice to step up and invest in Black feminist movements with the urgency and abundance required"

The Myths of Philanthropy series is being published in collaboration with the Center for Effective Philanthropy, Elemental, and VITA.

More coming soon!

New articles in this series will be regularly published on the Funders Collaborative Hub between April and June 2025. Subscribe to the Hub newsletter for updates.

Subscribe now

The Funders Collaborative Hub publishes a range of perspectives. The views expressed here are those of the authors, not necessarily those of ACF.